Website Redesign vs Website Updates: Which One Will Get You More Enquiries?

If you’re not getting the enquiries you want from your website, it’s easy to assume you need a full redesign. But for many small businesses in Bury St Edmunds and across Suffolk, a handful of focused improvements can make a big difference without rebuilding the whole site.

In this guide, I’ll explain the difference between a website redesign and website updates, how to tell which one you need, and the quickest way to get your website generating more enquiries.

I’m Anne at Afford Web Design — a WordPress specialist based in Bury St Edmunds. If you’d like an honest opinion on what your site needs,
book a free website review and I’ll send you a clear, plain-English action list.

Book a Free Website Review or explore website redesign options

Quick answer: redesign or updates?

• Choose website updates if your site is basically sound but needs clearer messaging, better calls to action, fresher content, speed tweaks or improved mobile usability.
• Choose a website redesign if your theme is outdated, the layout fights you, mobile is poor, speed is stubbornly slow, or you’re embarrassed to share the link.

Let’s break it down so you can choose the best route (and avoid spending money where you don’t need to).

What counts as a website update?

Website updates are improvements to your existing website without changing the whole structure or rebuilding the design. Think of it as “tidying and optimising” what you already have.

Common website updates include:

• Improving your homepage message so visitors instantly understand what you do
• Adding clearer calls to action (buttons, phone links, enquiry prompts)
• Updating service pages, pricing, photos and contact details
• Fixing mobile spacing, font sizes and navigation issues
• Speed improvements (image compression, caching, removing heavy scripts)
• Adding trust signals (testimonials, logos, reviews, case study snippets)
• Fixing broken forms, email delivery issues and small bugs

If that sounds like what you need, see website updates and content changes.

What counts as a website redesign?

A website redesign is a bigger step. It usually means rebuilding your website layout (and sometimes the structure) so it looks modern, works properly on mobile, loads faster and converts better.

A website redesign is the right choice when:

• Your site feels dated or doesn’t reflect your business anymore
• Mobile users struggle (pinch-zooming, tiny text, awkward menus)
• Your theme or builder makes small changes difficult and expensive
• The site is slow despite tweaks
• You want new pages, new services, or a stronger brand refresh
• You’re not confident in the site’s security or maintenance setup

If you’re ready for a cleaner, faster site that converts better, take a look at my website redesign services.

The real question: what’s stopping enquiries?

If you want more enquiries, the decision isn’t really “redesign vs updates” — it’s what is getting in the way of trust and action?

Here are the most common blockers I see on small business websites in Suffolk:

• Unclear messaging: visitors don’t quickly understand what you offer or who it’s for
• Weak calls to action: no obvious next step, or CTAs buried at the bottom
• Not enough proof: no testimonials, reviews or examples of work
• Poor mobile experience: fiddly buttons, cramped layouts, confusing menus
• Slow loading: people leave before the page finishes loading

Many of these can be fixed with updates — but if your theme is holding everything back, a redesign is the better long-term investment.

How to decide: a simple checklist

Use this checklist to choose the best route.

Website updates are usually enough if:

• Your site is mobile-friendly and basically easy to use
• You like the overall look, but it needs polishing
• You mainly need content changes, stronger CTAs or better trust signals
• Your site is reasonably quick, or could be quick with optimisation
• You want the most cost-effective improvement path

A redesign is usually the smarter option if:

• Your site looks outdated or doesn’t reflect your business now
• Mobile experience is poor or inconsistent
• The structure needs to change (new services, new navigation, clearer layout)
• You’ve tried fixing speed and it’s still slow
• Updating the site feels stressful or breaks things

What about WordPress maintenance — do you need it either way?

If your website is generating leads, you want to protect that.
Whether you choose updates or a redesign, ongoing care helps your site stay secure, fast and enquiry-ready.

My WordPress maintenance plans cover updates, backups, security checks and performance tuning — so you don’t have to worry about your website drifting over time.

Redesign + local SEO: a powerful combination for Suffolk businesses

If most of your customers are local, your website needs to support Google visibility as well as conversions. Design choices like mobile usability, speed and clear service pages can all influence local performance.

If you want to improve visibility in Maps and local search results, see local SEO in Suffolk.

Want an honest recommendation?

If you’re not sure whether you need a redesign or a few updates, I can help. Book a free review and I’ll tell you the simplest route to a clearer, faster website that wins more enquiries.

Book a Free Website Review
or explore small business web design in Suffolk

Frequently Asked Questions